Ellison, “‘Repent, Harlequin!’”; Delany, “Aye, and Gomorrah”; Tiptree, “And I Awoke”

ENG 108 · Lecture 15

Erik Fredner

Oregon State University

Tue Nov 17, 2026

Adapted from course materials by Evan Gottlieb.

Text version

The New Wave

What makes an SF story “New Wave”?

What are things that you noticed in Ballard, Ellison, Delany, or Tiptree that you would not find in Asimov?

What was “new” about the New Wave?

  • New Wave sought literary recognition for SF
  • New Worlds magazine in Britain, edited by Michael Moorcock from 1964; in the US, anthologies like Ellison’s Dangerous Visions
  • New Wave defines itself against the heroism of “Golden Age” (e.g., Asimov) SF
  • New topics: psychology, sociology, drugs, religion, politics, race, sex, class

Last time: Ballard

  • “Inner space.” “The only truly alien planet is Earth.”
  • Speculative fiction can be “realer” than realism
  • Narratives that are open-ended rather than closed (e.g., Asimov’s computer reverses entropy)
  • Experimental form: Fragmented, demanding, and literary

Dangerous Visions (1967)

  • Influential anthology of 33 new stories edited by Harlan Ellison
  • Commissioned as a collection of stories magazine editors were too scared to print (hence “dangerous”)
  • It won a special Hugo Award and defined the American New Wave.
  • “Aye, and Gomorrah” first appeared in it.
Dangerous Visions, first edition (Doubleday, 1967)

Harlan Ellison (1934–2018)

  • Born in Cleveland; wrote hundreds of stories plus essays, criticism, and screenplays, including Star Trek’s “The City on the Edge of Forever” (1967).
  • Editor of Dangerous Visions (1967) and Again, Dangerous Visions (1972)
  • “‘Repent, Harlequin!’ Said the Ticktockman” (Galaxy, 1965) won both the Hugo and the Nebula.
Ellison at the Los Angeles Press Club, 1986

What is utopian or dystopian about “‘Repent, Harlequin!’”?

Utopia/dystopia in “‘Repent, Harlequin!’”

  • Central planning with minute-by-minute time-management
  • A heroic individual resists the state by being late, but ultimately falls in line
  • The Harlequin is a trickster figure from the Italian commedia dell’arte; the Joker is a modern descendant, and his sidekick Harley Quinn is named for the Harlequin.
  • Power of mockery: It threatens the state to laugh at what it considers sacred (here, time)

Historical context: Taylorism

  • Frederick Winslow Taylor, The Principles of Scientific Management (1911): break every job into motions, time each with a stopwatch, and find the one most efficient way to do it.
    • e.g., Charlie Chaplin’s Modern Times (1936)
  • Henry Ford’s moving assembly line (1913) put Taylorism to work
  • Management sets the line, but the worker has to keep up
  • Is Amazon Taylorism globalized?
  • Ellison’s world runs on the same logic, except the Ticktockman has a cardioplate

Is the Harlequin heroic? If yes, should you be late to your next class?

A very few, as heroes, patriots, martyrs, reformers in the great sense, and men, serve the state with their consciences also, and so necessarily resist it for the most part; and they are commonly treated as enemies by it.

Henry David Thoreau, “Civil Disobedience” (1849), the story’s epigraph.

Samuel R. Delany (1942– )

  • Born in Harlem; wrote his first novel, The Jewels of Aptor (1962), at nineteen.
  • Won Nebulas for Babel-17 (1966), The Einstein Intersection (1967), and “Aye, and Gomorrah” (1967); Dhalgren (1975) sold close to a million copies.
  • A Black, gay writer and critic in a field that was neither; named an SFWA Grand Master in 2013.
Delany in his apartment, 2022

Delany on the purpose of SF

“Science fiction isn’t just thinking about the world out there. It’s also thinking about how that world might be — a particularly important exercise for those who are oppressed, because if they’re going to change the world we live in, they — and all of us — have to be able to think about a world that works differently.”

Delany, interviewed in The Paris Review 197 (Summer 2011).

How to read SF, according to Delany

  • Delany’s example sentence: “Her world exploded.”
    • In realism, this is a metaphor for a life suddenly falling apart, as with a death.
    • In SF, it could be literal. (Or it could be both literal and symbolic: The death of a planet as the death of a life that she had previously known.)
  • Delany calls this subjunctivity: the kind of claim a sentence makes about reality. Realism describes what could have happened; SF, what has not happened yet.1
  • As a result, SF needs its own reading protocols

What is the relationship between frelks and spacers?

“Aye, and Gomorrah”

  • We may move around Earth impossibly quickly, but the reader never goes to space.
  • Spacers are neutered (“not even androgynous,” says the frelk), and the story never gives them gendered pronouns
  • The title alludes to the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah, supposedly for their citizens’ deviant sex lives
  • The story itself condemns no one’s desires, though its characters judge each other constantly
  • Very different representation of sexuality from a lot of SF: scantily-clad stolen princesses, etc.

James Tiptree, Jr. (1915–1987)

  • Pen name of Alice B. Sheldon: Army Air Forces photo-intelligence officer in the Second World War, CIA analyst, and PhD in experimental psychology.
  • Took the pen name in 1967 from a jar of marmalade. Readers and fellow writers assumed Tiptree was a man.
  • Unmasked in 1976–77. The Tiptree Award (now the Otherwise Award), founded in 1991, honors SF that explores gender.
Alice and Huntington Sheldon, 1946

Compare and contrast the types of “deviance” that Delany and Tiptree’s stories discuss

“And I Awoke and Found Me Here on the Cold Hill’s Side”

  • The title comes from Keats’s poem “La Belle Dame sans Merci” (1819), where a knight is ruinously enchanted by a faery woman.
  • The novum is unreciprocated desire.
  • The engineer compares humanity to “the poor damned Polynesians,” trading away Earth’s resources for alien status symbols.
    • The analogy is to unfair colonial exchanges: “Swapping raw resources for junk… Tape decks, Coca-Cola, Mickey Mouse watches.”
  • The newsman ignores the engineer’s warning, and runs after aliens.

On women publishing as men

  • Women adopt male pen names as a strategy to be taken seriously in patriarchal cultures
  • Old strategy: The Brontës published as Currer, Ellis, and Acton Bell (1846–47); Mary Ann Evans as George Eliot; in SF, Alice Mary Norton as Andre Norton.
  • Queer theory argues that gender is a performance and feminist SF has been exposing that since its beginnings.2
    • For Judith Butler, drag is a quintessential example of gender as performance.
  • Literary style is another performance. Critics read Tiptree’s style as masculine: Robert Silverberg called it “ineluctably masculine.”

Undercutting SF tropes

The heroic spacefarer

  • Trope: The astronaut or space captain as hero: Buck Rogers, Flash Gordon, Captain Kirk.
  • Delany: Spacers are neutered laborers, “building water-conservation units on Mars, programming mining computers on Ganymede, servicing communication relay towers on the moon.”
  • Tiptree: the engineer has “two degrees” and does “Tube cleaning. A swab.” Humanity’s future in space is “serving as freight monkeys and junction crews” for aliens who will never love them back.

First contact

  • Trope: Meeting aliens is a turning point in human history.
  • Tiptree: the newsman assumes his source is “A xenophobe. Aliens plot to take over Earth,” but actually “they couldn’t care less.”
  • Delany: there are no aliens at all; the interesting point of contact is spacers. The strangers are humans the state has altered, and the contact that matters happens back on Earth, in Paris, Matamoros, and Istanbul.

Wonder

  • Trope: awe at the vastness of space and the strangeness of alien life
  • Tiptree: the newsman wants “the wonders, the drama,” to which the engineer responds, “You consummated fool.” It’s all “supernormal stimulus.”
  • Delany: the frelk feels wonder not for aliens but for people who the state desexed: “You have your glorious, soaring life … We have our dull, circled lives, bound in gravity, worshiping you!”

Which of these stories do you think was the most “dangerous” in 1967? Why?

The late 1960s were a period of major change in the US—the end of Jim Crow, sexual liberation, the new left, etc. These stories are a part of those changes.

Disco Elysium

Play Disco Elysium soon

  • Tue Dec 1: class on Disco Elysium. Play at least three hours before then.
  • Thanksgiving falls in between
  • I recommend playing this week.
  • Don’t forget that you can play for free at the New Media Game Lab in Snell Hall, Room 100B

Getting started

IGN’s guide covers character creation, skills, and the first steps:

ign.com/wikis/disco-elysium/Getting_started

For Thursday

  • “Vaster Than Empires and More Slow” by Ursula K. Le Guin (BBSF 577–595)
  • “When It Changed” by Joanna Russ (BBSF 602–607)