Quiz
Carrington, “The Debutante”
Leonora Carrington, 1917–2011
- English Surrealist painter and writer, born to a wealthy Lancashire family
- Presented at court as a debutante herself, then left home in 1937 for Paris and the painter Max Ernst
- From 1942, made Mexico City her home, with long stays in New York and Chicago
- “The Debutante” was written in French and published in La Dame ovale (1939), with collages by Ernst
Which symbols did you interpret in “The Debutante?”
Reading for symbolism
A symbol is a concrete thing in a story that stands for something larger than itself, often a feeling or idea that is hard to say directly. Examples:
- The hyena — the narrator’s wild, hungry, blunt self; the one creature she can talk to
- The face — the role a debutante is made to wear; taken, literally, from the maid
- The ball — being “presented” to society, for marriage, almost like an auction or sale
- “I smell a little strong” / “I do not eat cake” — the body and the appetite that the ball suppresses
J. R. R. Tolkien, 1892–1973
- Born in Bloemfontein, South Africa; orphaned at twelve and raised as the ward of a Catholic priest in Birmingham
- Fought at the Somme in 1916: “By 1918 all but one of my close friends were dead.”
- A philologist who worked on the Oxford English Dictionary, then taught Old and Middle English at Leeds (1920–25) and Oxford (1925–59)
- Invented languages like Elvish first, and later a world for them to be spoken in
Tolkien’s major works
| 1937 | The Hobbit |
| 1939 | “On Fairy-Stories” (a lecture; published 1947) |
| 1945 | “Leaf by Niggle” |
| 1954–55 | The Lord of the Rings, in three volumes |
| 1964 | Tree and Leaf — the essay and the story, together |
| 1967 | Smith of Wootton Major |
| 1977 | The Silmarillion, posthumous, edited by his son Christopher |
| 1983–96 | The History of Middle-earth, twelve volumes of drafts |
How does symbolism figure in “Leaf by Niggle?”
This could include, but is not limited to, “the gift.”
“It’s a gift!”
“‘It’s a gift!’ he said. He was referring to his art, and also to the result; but he was using the word quite literally.”
- Gift as artistic talent
- Gift as a present
- Gift as recognition that the work is complete
- The Second Voice is the gift-giver
“On Fairy-Stories”
Tolkien offers three uses of fantasy:
- Recovery — of the vividness of our perceptions
- Escape — from the quotidian, from modernity, even from death
- Consolation — the imaginative satisfaction of ancient desires, including but not limited to a happy ending
How does the theme of recovery work in “Leaf by Niggle?”
Recovery
“We need, in any case, to clean our windows; so that the things seen clearly may be freed from the drab blur of triteness or familiarity — from possessiveness. […] the things that are trite, or (in a bad sense) familiar, are the things that we have appropriated, legally or mentally. We say we know them.”
Councillor Tompkins has appropriated Niggle’s house.
How does Tolkien’s idea of the sub-creator appear in “Leaf by Niggle?”
The sub-creator
“What really happens is that the story-maker proves a successful ‘sub-creator.’ He makes a Secondary World which your mind can enter. Inside it, what he relates is ‘true’: it accords with the laws of that world. […] The moment disbelief arises, the spell is broken […]. You are then out in the Primary World again, looking at the little abortive Secondary World from outside.”
Parish and Atkins are, at times, inside and outside of Niggle’s secondary world.
Tolkien on making a secondary world
“Probably every writer making a secondary world, a fantasy, every sub-creator, wishes in some measure to be a real maker, or hopes that he is drawing on reality: hopes that the peculiar quality of this secondary world (if not all the details) are derived from Reality, or are flowing into it. If he indeed achieves a quality that can fairly be described by the dictionary definition: ‘inner consistency of reality,’ it is difficult to conceive how this can be, if the work does not in some way partake of reality. The peculiar quality of the ‘joy’ in successful Fantasy can thus be explained as a sudden glimpse of the underlying reality or truth.”
Stanley Cavell on fantasy and reality
Fantasy and consensus reality are interdependent:
“It is a poor idea of fantasy which takes it to be a world apart from reality, a world clearly showing its unreality. Fantasy is precisely what reality can be confused with. It is through fantasy that our conviction of the worth of reality is established; to forgo our fantasies would be to forgo our touch with the world.”
Stanley Cavell, The World Viewed: Reflections on the Ontology of Film (Harvard University Press, 1979), 85.
Is “Leaf by Niggle” an allegory about writing fantasy?
Allegory review
Allegories are narratives in which characters and features stand for specific things in the real world.
Examples:
- Dr. Seuss’s Butter Battle Book: The butter-side-uppers vs. -downers represent the USA vs. USSR in the nuclear arms race
- George Orwell’s Animal Farm: Napoleon the pig is Stalin
- John Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress: The protagonist Christian is an everyman representing the struggles faced by Christians in living their faith (e.g., getting stuck in the Slough of Despond due to sin)
Tolkien’s view of allegory
- Tolkien resisted allegorical readings of his work.
- Many have argued that the One Ring in Lord of the Rings could be read as an allegory for nuclear weapons.
- Tolkien rejected that reading.
“Leaf by Niggle” as allegory for writing fantasy
- Seems to invite the interpretation!
- Niggle is Tolkien
- Beautiful leaves are finished stories (e.g., The Hobbit)
- The unfinished painting is Middle-earth
- But Niggle’s journey makes the allegory unstable
Do you think that “Leaf by Niggle” is an allegory?
If it is an allegory, of what? Writing fantasy specifically? Creating art generally?
Another tradition for “Leaf:” The Künstlerroman
German: the “artist-novel,” the story of an artist’s growth into their art.
- Themes include young, starving artists; unfinished masterpieces; worlds that are not ready for an artist or their work; and the artist’s rejection of the world as it is in order to pursue art.
- Famous literary examples: Joyce, A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man (1916); Woolf, To the Lighthouse (1927); Vuong, On Earth We’re Briefly Gorgeous (2019)
High fantasy, low fantasy
| High fantasy (Tolkien) | Low fantasy, or sword and sorcery (Howard) | |
|---|---|---|
| world | a whole secondary world: maps, languages, histories | a backdrop of decadent kingdoms |
| stakes | the fate of the world | a life, a throne, treasure |
| hero | a hobbit, a fellowship, a king in exile | a lone barbarian outsider |
| magic | ancient, numinous, and a temptation | rare, evil, and the enemy |
| morality | good against evil; providence | survival; violence solves it |
| form | the multivolume quest | the pulp short story |
Both are set in an imagined prehistory of Earth: Middle-earth and the Thurian Age.
Fantasy after Tolkien
Why BBCF ends here
- “Leaf by Niggle” (1945) is the last story in the anthology1
- Tolkien is almost indisputably the most influential Anglophone fantasy author, especially for fantasy of the last 75 years.
- Everything in BBCF precedes the historical moment that we are now in, where there is a Fantasy section in bookstores (usually next to the Science Fiction section)
- Tolkien’s success demonstrated a demand in the market for fantasy that publishers were eager to supply
The paperback wars
- 1954–55: Allen & Unwin splits The Lord of the Rings into three volumes to cut costs. Tolkien wrote one novel, but fantasy picks up the trilogy due to this publishing decision.
- 1965: Ace prints an unauthorized paperback through a gap in the US copyright; Ballantine answers with the authorized one. Fantasy reaches the US mass market.
- 1969–74: Ballantine Adult Fantasy reprints the pre-Tolkien canon — Dunsany, Morris, MacDonald, Cabell — for readers who want more.
- 1977: Del Rey’s The Sword of Shannara, aimed at Tolkien fans, is the first novel on the New York Times trade paperback bestseller list.
The result: a fantasy shelf in Tolkien’s shape — series, map, Dark Lord, quest.
Tolkien’s influence on later fantasy
- The template: elves, dwarves, orcs; a Dark Lord; a fellowship; a map
- Tabletop Games: Dungeons & Dragons (1974) had hobbits until the rights holders objected; they became “halflings”
- Answering him: Ursula K. Le Guin’s Earthsea (1968–); George R. R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire (1996–), which asks “What was Aragorn’s tax policy?”
- Film: Peter Jackson’s trilogy (2001–03); The Return of the King won eleven Academy Awards
- Video games like Baldur’s Gate 3 (2023) enact Tolkien and D&D
Ann VanderMeer and Jeff VanderMeer, eds., The Big Book of Classic Fantasy: The Ultimate Collection (Vintage Crime/Black Lizard, Vintage Books, 2019).↩︎