Part I. Reading Check

  1. In Ellison’s story, under the Master Timekeeper’s system, a citizen who is ten minutes late:

    1. is fined ten minutes’ pay by their employer
    2. loses ten minutes from the end of their life Answer
    3. is sent to Coventry to be retrained
    4. loses the right to vote in the next election
  2. Ellison interrupts the Harlequin’s adventures with what the narrator calls a “footnote”: Marshall Delahanty receives a turn-off notice, runs two hundred miles into the forest, and dies running. The narrator ends it, “don’t laugh […] It isn’t funny.” The footnote’s point is that:

    1. the Harlequin’s pranks are funny, but the system he mocks really kills Answer
    2. the Ticktockman makes mistakes, and sometimes turns off the wrong man
    3. people who flee the city are beyond the Ticktockman’s reach
    4. the Delahantys reported the Harlequin to the authorities
  3. In Delany’s story, define each term in a phrase or a sentence.

    Spacer:

    Frelk:

    Model answer

    Spacer: a person altered (neutered) before puberty so they can work beyond the ionosphere, on the moon, Mars, or Jupiter’s satellites, where radiation would otherwise damage their reproductive organs.

    Frelk: a person sexually attracted to spacers, said to have a “free-fall-sexual-displacement complex.”

  4. In Delany’s story, when the narrator leaves the woman’s room, the woman suggests the Flower Passage, which turns out to be:

    1. the frelk hangout where Bo’s platoon once beat two people
    2. a spacer hangout, where the narrator finds the rest of the crew Answer
    3. the market where she bought the dolmades she served
    4. the street where a gas main once exploded
  5. In Tiptree’s story, the red-haired man asks about “supernormal stimuli” and describes a bird that rolls its own egg out of the nest to sit on a bigger, brighter fake. He means that humans:

    1. are being tricked by aliens who disguise themselves as human
    2. are drawn to aliens more strongly than to one another, and abandon their own Answer
    3. will soon be unable to have children because of gamma radiation
    4. are being bred by the aliens as servants for their stations

Part II. Delany and Tiptree

Read the two passages below. The question on the next page asks you to compare them.

Delany. In “Aye, and Gomorrah,” the woman in the park in Istanbul speaks to the narrator:

“Perverted, yes? In love with a bunch of corpses in free fall!” […] “I don’t like having a free-fall-sexual-displacement complex.”

[…]

“You don’t choose your perversions. You have no perversions at all. You’re free of the whole business. I love you for that, Spacer. My love starts with the fear of love. Isn’t that beautiful? A pervert substitutes something unattainable for ‘normal’ love: the homosexual, a mirror, the fetishist, a shoe or a watch or a girdle. Those with free-fall-sexual-dis—”

“Frelks.”

“Frelks substitute—” she looked at me sharply again—“loose, swinging meat.”

Tiptree. In “And I Awoke and Found Me Here on the Cold Hill’s Side,” the red-haired man speaks to the newsman:

“Little Junction was the place where the lower orders went, the clerks and drivers out for kicks. Including, my friend, the perverts. The ones who can take humans. Into their beds, that is.”

[…]

“I’d trade—correction, I have traded—everything Earth offered me for just that chance. To see them. To speak to them. Once in a while to touch one. Once in a great while to find one low enough, perverted enough to want to touch me . . .”

[…]

“We’ve hit the supernormal stimulus. Man is exogamous—all our history is one long drive to find and impregnate the stranger. […] But now we’ve met aliens we can’t screw, and we’re about to die trying. . . . . Do you think I can touch my wife?”

  1. Both speakers use the word “pervert.” How does each one define and describe sexual deviance? Who counts as deviant, and what makes a desire deviant? Then compare and contrast how the two characters respond to what they know about their own sexual preferences. Refer to specific words in both passages.

    Model answer

    Strong answers notice that the two speakers define deviance in different ways, and that both know exactly what they want without being freed by knowing it.

    The woman defines deviance the way a psychology textbook of the 1960s would. “A pervert substitutes something unattainable for ‘normal’ love,” and her list puts “the homosexual” beside the fetishist’s “shoe or a watch or a girdle.” Frelks fit the pattern: they substitute “loose, swinging meat” for a partner who could love them back, and she even has a clinical name for it, “a free-fall-sexual-displacement complex.” It is striking that Delany, a gay writer, puts that list in her mouth, in a story whose title points to Sodom and Gomorrah. Her definition is the society’s, and the story lets us notice how much it lumps together.

    The red-haired man defines deviance in two directions. Among the aliens, the “perverts” are “the ones who can take humans,” so wanting a human is what is perverse, and he can only hope to find an alien “low enough, perverted enough to want to touch me.” For humans, though, he says the desire is not a perversion at all. It is natural: “Man is exogamous,” and the drive to find “the stranger” is built in. The problem is that it has met a “supernormal stimulus” it was never made for.

    Both know themselves completely, and knowing does not help either of them. The woman responds with irony and a kind of acceptance. “You don’t choose your perversions,” she says, and she can even call her own fear “beautiful,” while admitting “I don’t like having” it. She keeps looking for spacers anyway. The red-haired man responds with self-hatred and a demand that others be stopped: he wants Earth to “close the ports,” but he has “traded everything” himself and stays, drugged and bitter. The saddest line is “Do you think I can touch my wife?” His desire for aliens has made human partners impossible. For her the desire is a private condition to live with; for him it is a disaster for the whole species, and warning about it does not work, since the newsman runs off after the aliens as soon as he leaves.

Part III. Ellison

Early in the story, the narrator explains how lateness came to be punished:

[…] one day we no longer let time serve us, we serve time and we are slaves of the schedule, worshippers of the sun’s passing, bound into a life predicated on restrictions because the system will not function if we don’t keep the schedule tight.

Until it becomes more than a minor inconvenience to be late.

It becomes a sin. Then a crime.

Near the end, after the Harlequin is caught, the Ticktockman questions him:

“Repent, Harlequin!” said the Ticktockman.

“Get stuffed!” the Harlequin replied, sneering.

[…]

“I’m not going to turn you off.”

“You’re an idiot!”

“Repent, Harlequin!” said the Ticktockman.

“Get stuffed.”

  1. Connect the two passages. Lateness becomes “a sin” before it becomes “a crime,” and the Ticktockman, who could simply turn the Harlequin off, demands instead that he “Repent!” Why does this society treat lateness in religious terms, and why does the Ticktockman want repentance rather than obedience or death? Does the Harlequin repent by the end of the story?

    Model answer

    The first passage shows that the schedule became a religion before it became a law. People are “worshippers of the sun’s passing,” and lateness turns into “a sin” first and only then “a crime.” The order matters: by the time there is a law, everyone already believes being late is wrong, not just inconvenient. The law only enforces a faith people already hold.

    That explains “Repent!” You repent a sin, not a mistake, so the Ticktockman is acting like a priest as much as a policeman. Punishing a crime only needs the body, and he could do that any time, but he says “I’m not going to turn you off.” Killing the Harlequin would make him a martyr, the kind of person Thoreau’s epigraph calls a hero for resisting the state with his conscience. What the system needs is his conscience: he has to admit, in public, that he was wrong, so that everyone else stops believing he might have been right. “Get stuffed,” repeated twice, is a refusal to confess, not just to obey.

    He does seem to repent in the end. After he is “sent to Coventry” and worked over, as in 1984, he goes on the public screens and says “it was a good, a very good thing indeed, to belong,” and people decide “he was just a nut after all.” That is exactly the confession the system wanted. But the story does not fully believe it. The narrator says he looked “not at all brainwashed,” and in the last scene even the Ticktockman is “three minutes late.” The Harlequin said the words of repentance, but the disorder he started has spread to the priest himself.