Part I. Beyond Lies the Wub

  1. Why are the crew so interested in whether the wub is good to eat?

    1. Spoiled supplies leave them short of food for a month. Answer
    2. Wub meat sells for a high price in the markets of Earth.
    3. The natives say that eating a wub brings a long life.
    4. The cook wants to test whether Martian meat is safe.
  2. The wub explains that it speaks English because it:

    1. learned it from earlier expeditions from Earth
    2. was taught it by the native who sold it
    3. overheard the crew talking in the hold
    4. read the language in the Captain’s mind Answer
  3. When Franco says “Nuts to you” and opens his office door, he:

    1. fires at the wub, but misses
    2. freezes, mouth open, as the wub walks past Answer
    3. orders the crew to lock the wub in the hold
    4. falls asleep at his desk until the crew wakes him
  4. “Your scientific hierarchy is not equipped to solve moral, ethical—” It faults humans for:

    1. advancing in technology but not in morality Answer
    2. relying on atomic power instead of farming
    3. refusing to share their science with older races
    4. running their ship’s jets too hot for comfort
  5. Bradbury’s “The Martian” gives us an alien who seems threatening but is vulnerable. Dick reverses this. His alien:

    1. seems threatening, and turns out to be harmless after all
    2. seems threatening, and turns out to be even more dangerous
    3. seems harmless, and turns out to be far more powerful Answer
    4. seems harmless, and turns out to be a native in disguise

Early in “Beyond Lies the Wub,” the wub talks with Peterson:

“As I interpret it, Odysseus wanders as an individual, aware of himself as such. This is the idea of separation, of separation from family and country. The process of individuation.”

“But Odysseus returns to his home.” […] “Finally he goes home.”

“As must all creatures. The moment of separation is a temporary period, a brief journey of the soul. It begins, it ends. The wanderer returns to land and race….”

The story ends at dinner, after the crew has eaten the wub. The Captain speaks to Peterson:

“As I was saying before I was interrupted, the role of Odysseus in the myths—”

Peterson jerked up, staring.

“To go on,” the Captain said. “Odysseus, as I understand him—”

  1. Interpret the return of Odysseus at the end of the story. What has happened to the Captain, and how does the wub’s reading of Odysseus help explain it?

    Model answer

    The wub has not died; it has moved into the man who ate it. “As I was saying before I was interrupted” is the wub’s sentence, not Franco’s: it was the wub, talking to Peterson, who was interrupted when Franco and the crew came in with a gun. Franco never cared about myths—when the wub offered him “philosophy, the arts,” he said “Nuts to you.” Now he picks up the wub’s lecture mid-thought, which is why Peterson, the one person who heard the first half, jerks up in horror.

    The wub’s reading of Odysseus explains what this means. For the wub, being a separate individual is only “a temporary period,” and “the wanderer returns to land and race.” Franco, the most self-assured individual on the ship, has lost exactly that: his separate self has been absorbed into the wub, the “very old” race, just as the wanderer is absorbed back into his people. It also explains why the wub said “It doesn’t matter” when Franco came to shoot it. A creature that believes separation is temporary has no reason to fear the death of one body. The man who insisted the wub was only a hog is the one who has been consumed.

Part II. The Snowball Effect

  1. Who narrates “The Snowball Effect”?

    1. Professor Wilton Caswell, the sociologist
    2. Halloway, the university’s president Answer
    3. Mrs. Searles, chairman of the sewing circle
    4. a student who surveyed Watashaw for Caswell
  2. Why does Caswell agree to run the experiment at all?

    1. He hopes to prove that the United Nations will fail.
    2. Washington has hired him to test a federal corporation.
    3. Mrs. Searles asks him to help her sewing circle grow.
    4. Halloway demands proof that his field is worth funding. Answer
  3. Halloway calls himself “a well-dressed panhandler” who spends the year “going hat in hand, asking politely for money at everyone’s door.” His view of a university is that it is:

    1. a business, in which each department must pay its way Answer
    2. a community of scholars who should be left free to think
    3. a branch of government, funded and run by Washington
    4. a charity, like the sewing circle, that serves the poor
  4. Halloway and Caswell choose the Watashaw Sewing Circle because:

    1. it already had thousands of members statewide
    2. Mrs. Searles was once a student of Caswell’s
    3. no one would expect so small a club to grow Answer
    4. its members had asked to take part in a study
  5. What do the two men actually give the sewing circle?

    1. money for six months of charity work
    2. a diagram of organization and new bylaws Answer
    3. a speech on civic pride, given by Caswell
    4. a list of new members from the university
  6. Caswell compares the organization to “the great stock boom before an economic crash.” Like a stock boom, the organization:

    1. grows slowly and steadily, so it can never crash
    2. is run by bankers who know exactly when to sell
    3. can be stopped at will by the man who designed it
    4. pays off while it grows, and falls apart if it stops Answer
  7. By the end, the club is called “Civic Property Pool and Social Dividend, membership contractual, open to all,” and has opened a branch in New York. Halloway’s graph predicts that:

    1. the rest of the world will join in about twelve years Answer
    2. it will collapse once every woman in Watashaw joins
    3. it will shrink back to a sewing circle within the year
    4. the New York branch will close within a few months
  8. The story ends: “But I don’t want anyone to pin that on me. From now on, if anyone asks me, I’ve never heard of Watashaw.” What does this ending say about Halloway, and about the responsibility of the people who build such systems?

    Model answer

    Halloway started the experiment to raise money, not to understand anything, and he treated it as a joke: he and Caswell “didn’t start laughing until our car passed the town limits.” Even when the club was taking over the town’s real estate, he “chuckled” and thought about the money it would bring in “in carload lots.” Only when he sees that the snowball cannot be stopped—“if I tried to stop it now, they’d cut my throat,” Caswell says—does he start to worry.

    His response is not to fix it or confess, but to deny he was ever there. He has already been using an alias, “Professor Smith,” so in a sense he planned to be untraceable from the start. The ending suggests that the people who design a powerful system are tempted to treat what it does as an accident that has nothing to do with them. MacLean makes him funny and likeable, which is the point: an ordinary administrator chasing a donation can set off something enormous and then simply walk away from it.

Part III. 2BR02B

  1. Read aloud, with the zero as “naught,” the title “2BR02B” says “To be or not to be.” The line comes from:

    1. Shakespeare’s Macbeth
    2. Marlowe’s Doctor Faustus
    3. Shakespeare’s Hamlet Answer
    4. Milton’s Paradise Lost
  2. Why does Wehling have to find volunteers to die?

    1. He owes the Bureau of Termination a debt he cannot pay.
    2. A newborn may live only if someone dies in its place. Answer
    3. Each family must give the Bureau one member a year.
    4. The hospital will not release his wife until he does.
  3. The gas chambers are called “Automat,” “Catbox,” “Happy Hooligan,” and “Weep-no-more,” and officially “Ethical Suicide Studios.” Leora Duncan objects to the nicknames because they:

    1. were made up by Dr. Hitz, whom she dislikes
    2. make callers dial the wrong telephone number
    3. are forbidden by the Bureau’s own regulations
    4. give people “the wrong impression” of her work Answer
  4. In the mural, “The Happy Garden of Life,” the figures in white plant and tend, while the figures in purple:

    1. pull weeds and cut down old or sickly plants Answer
    2. water the garden and harvest its ripe fruit
    3. guard the garden’s gates against intruders
    4. carry new seedlings in from beyond the walls
  5. Asked what life really looks like, the painter points to a foul dropcloth: “Frame that, and you’ll have a picture a damn sight more honest than this one.” He means that:

    1. his own skill as a painter has declined with age
    2. the mural is unfinished, and still too messy to show
    3. the tidy mural hides the killing the society needs Answer
    4. good art should never show anything ugly or dirty
  6. Wehling shoots Dr. Hitz, then Leora Duncan, then himself. “There’s room for one—a great big one,” he says. The terrible irony is that:

    1. he dies without saving any of his three children
    2. he follows the law’s own rule: a death for each birth Answer
    3. the shots bring the hospital staff running too late
    4. Dr. Hitz had already found him three volunteers
  7. The hostess thanks the painter: “Your city thanks you; your country thanks you; your planet thanks you. But the deepest thanks of all is from future generations.” Coming after the shootings, this line is:

    1. sincere: the painter is proud to die for the future
    2. a warning: she is trying to talk him out of dying
    3. a mistake: she has confused him with another caller
    4. ironic: it thanks him for a death it drove him to Answer
  8. Does “2BR02B” depict a utopia or a dystopia? Use evidence from the story to support your claim.

    Model answer

    Either claim can earn full credit if the evidence supports it. Strong answers notice that the story presents a utopia on its surface and shows what that surface hides.

    “2BR02B” depicts a dystopia that calls itself a utopia. The opening reads like a list of utopian promises: “There were no prisons, no slums, no insane asylums, no cripples, no poverty, no wars,” and Dr. Hitz promises a “happy, roomy, clean, rich planet.” But the story shows that this perfection is kept up by killing. The law says “no newborn child could survive unless the parents of the child could find someone who would volunteer to die,” so Wehling must choose which of his triplets will live and deliver his grandfather to the gas chamber.

    The mural makes the point visually. “The Happy Garden of Life” is “neat” and “formal,” but half its gardeners wear the purple of the Bureau of Termination and “cut down plants that were old and sickly.” The painter says a filthy dropcloth would be “a damn sight more honest.” The cheerful nicknames (“Happy Hooligan,” “Weep-no-more”) and the official title “Ethical Suicide Studios” work the same way: the society’s language makes death sound pleasant. By the end, three people are dead in the waiting room, “nobody came running,” and the painter calls to book his own death while the hostess thanks him on behalf of “future generations.” A world that has to hide that much to look perfect is a dystopia.