Part I. Sword and Sorcery
Sword and sorcery is a subgenre of fantasy, sometimes called low fantasy. Its hero is a formidable warrior, often an outsider from a “barbarian” background, who solves problems by fighting. The stakes are personal or local, such as survival, a throne, or treasure, rather than the fate of the world. Magic is rare, ancient, and usually evil, and the hero fights it rather than using it. The settings are invented or lost pre-modern worlds, often decadent civilizations in decline, and the stories mix action with horror. The best-known example is Howard’s later hero, Conan the Barbarian.
Apply this definition to “The Shadow Kingdom.” Which elements of sword and sorcery does the story have? Point to specific moments.
Model answer
Kull fits the hero almost exactly. He is an outsider, an Atlantean and not a Valusian, and he took the throne by force with “the swift whirl of swords.” He still thinks of himself as a savage and doesn’t fit in at court. He solves problems by fighting. When Brule shows him the serpent-man in the corridor, Brule just says “Slay!”, and at the end Kull kills a whole room of serpent-men by going berserk.
The magic is ancient and evil, and it belongs to the enemy. The serpent-men come from an older world and can take human faces. Kull and Brule have no magic of their own, just a password and a dragon armlet to tell real men from fake ones.
The setting fits too. Valusia is “fading” and “degenerate,” living on its past glory. The stakes are Kull’s life and his throne, not the whole world. And the story mixes action with horror, like when a dead man’s face turns into a snake’s.
Part II. Race
Read both passages, then answer the question about one of them.
Passage A. Kull, king of Valusia but born in Atlantis, receives the Pictish envoy Brule:
They eyed each other silently, their mutual tribal enmity seething beneath their cloak of formality. Their mouths spoke the cultured speech, the conventional court phrases of a highly polished race, a race not their own, but from their eyes gleamed the primal traditions of the elemental savage.
Passage B. Brule tells Kull the history of the serpent-men:
The snake-people were the last to go, yet at last men conquered even them and drove them forth into the waste lands of the world, there to mate with true snakes until some day, say the sages, the horrid breed shall vanish utterly. Yet the Things returned in crafty guise as men grew soft and degenerate, forgetting ancient wars. […] No man knew who was true man and who false.
Choose one passage and use it to explain the role that race plays in “The Shadow Kingdom.” Then compare that role with ideas about race in the United States in 1929, when the story was published.
Model answer
This answer uses Passage B. An answer on Passage A might note that “race” in the story means peoples like the Atlanteans and Picts, that each has a fixed nature that court manners only cover up, and that Kull and Brule still become friends across that line.
I chose Passage B. The serpent-men are treated as a race, a “horrid breed” that was driven out and is supposed to die out by mating with snakes. The scary thing about them is that they look exactly like humans, so “no man knew who was true man and who false.” The story needs tests to tell them apart, like the password that only a real human mouth can say. They come back when humans get “soft and degenerate,” and the story’s answer is to kill them all. Kull swears to hunt them “from land to land.”
This is a lot like how race worked in the US in 1929. The South had Jim Crow segregation, including Texas where Howard lived. States like Virginia had “one-drop” laws, where any Black ancestry made you legally Black, and banned interracial marriage. Eugenicists warned that “race mixing” would make white civilization degenerate. People worried about “passing,” and Nella Larsen’s novel Passing came out the same year as the story. The serpent-men match these fears: an enemy who looks like you, has to be detected, and must not mix.
But the story is also different. Its hero is the “savage” outsider, not the civilized Valusians. Kull and Brule come from enemy peoples and become friends anyway. And the line the story cares most about is between humans and monsters, not between human races. You could read that as Howard moving past the racism of his time, or as hiding it inside a fantasy about monsters.
Part III. Political Intrigue
“The Shadow Kingdom” is full of political intrigue between kingdoms and peoples: alliances, plots, usurpers, and enemies at court. Describe the role that intrigue plays in the story. Then compare it to a later work of fantasy, such as Game of Thrones (or George R. R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire).
Model answer
Any later fantasy with political intrigue works.
Kull got the throne through plotting himself, and now people are plotting against him. He is an Atlantean ruling Valusia, and he is allied with the Picts, who used to be his people’s enemies. He feels like the court is a “masquerade” where everyone hides behind a mask. Ka-nu, the Pictish ambassador, is the real politician. He helps Kull because a strong Valusia is good for the Picts, not because he likes him. The serpent-men turn the court’s masks into real ones. They have been secretly replacing kings and councilors for a long time, so Kull can’t trust anyone. Kull is good with a sword but bad at politics, and he only survives because Ka-nu and Brule help him.
Game of Thrones is similar. The kingdoms and houses make alliances they don’t really believe in, Robert Baratheon is a king who took the throne by force, and Littlefinger and Varys use people the way Ka-nu does. Ned Stark is an honest fighter who doesn’t understand the court, kind of like Kull. Both stories also have an old monster threat that the humans forgot about while they fought each other: the serpent-men and the White Walkers. The difference is that Kull wins and the plot gets resolved. In Game of Thrones the good guys often lose, and Ned dies because he isn’t good at the game.
Part IV. Style
Each passage below describes a transformation.
Passage A. From “The Shadow Kingdom.” A warrior who looks exactly like Brule has come to Kull’s study:
Kull bent forward; from the corner of his eye he saw a blur of movement, a glint of steel. Like a loosened bow he whipped erect, thrusting upward. The warrior sagged upon the sword, his own clattering to the floor. Even at that instant Kull reflected grimly that it was appropriate that the traitor should meet his death upon the sliding, upward thrust used so much by his race. Then, as Brule slid from the sword to sprawl motionless on the floor, the face began to merge and fade, and as Kull caught his breath, his hair a-prickle, the human features vanished and there the jaws of a great snake gaped hideously, the terrible beady eyes venomous even in death.
“He was a snake priest all the time!” gasped the king.
Passage B. From “Uncle Monday.” A month after Uncle Monday was found with his arm “all but torn away,” two hunters pass Lake Belle:
They say the thing they took for the ’gator then struggled awhile, pulling off something that looked like a long black glove. Then he scraped a hole in the soft ground with his paws and carefully buried the glove which had come from his right paw. Then without looking either right or left; he stood upright and walked on toward the village. Everybody saw Uncle Monday come thru the town, but still Merchant’s tale was hard to swallow. But, by degrees, people came to believe that Uncle Monday could shed any injured member of his body and grow a new one in its place. At any rate, when he reappeared his right hand and arm bore no scars.
Passage C. The end of Mourning Dove’s “Coyote Juggles His Eyes”:
His eyes returned to their places, and Coyote ran to the top of a hill.
There he looked back and shouted: “Where are the maidens who had Coyote for a grandmother?”
Bluejay and Bluebird were full of shame. They went home carrying Pheasant’s skin, which Coyote had thrown aside. They searched and found their grandmother’s body and put it back in the skin, and Pheasant’s life was restored. She told them how Coyote had killed her with the stinging bush.
Describe the style of each passage. Consider word choice, sentence structure, and who is telling the story and how they claim to know it.
Model answer
Howard uses long sentences with lots of clauses, comparisons (“Like a loosened bow”), and dramatic adjectives like “hideously,” “terrible,” and “venomous.” Some words are old-fashioned, like “a-prickle.” The narrator knows everything and tells us what Kull sees and feels in the moment.
Hurston’s sentences are plainer and start with “Then” and “But” a lot. The narrator is like someone from the town repeating what “they say.” She isn’t sure it’s true: the thing only “looked like” a glove, and the story was “hard to swallow.”
Mourning Dove’s sentences are short and simple and joined with “and,” like a story told out loud. There are almost no adjectives, and the narrator doesn’t comment. Something impossible, like Pheasant coming back to life, is told just like something ordinary.
Compare and contrast how each style shapes the meaning of the transformation it describes. Why might each writer have chosen that style for that transformation?
Model answer
Howard’s style makes the transformation scary. The long sentence builds up until the face finally turns into a snake at the end, and all the adjectives make it as gross as possible. The narrator doesn’t leave any doubt that it really happened. That makes sense for sword and sorcery, because the monster has to be clearly a monster so the hero can kill it.
Hurston’s style makes the transformation something people believe in rather than something we see for sure. Because the narrator only repeats what people say, we end up in the same place as the townspeople. We don’t know what Uncle Monday really is, but we know to be careful around him. Hurston collected folklore as an anthropologist, so it makes sense that she tells it the way a community would.
Mourning Dove’s style makes the transformation normal. Eyes going back in and a dead grandmother coming back to life get the same simple sentences as Coyote running up a hill, so there’s no shock. In this world things like that just happen. It’s a funny trickster story, not a horror story, and the simple style fits a story meant to be told out loud and remembered.
Part V. Shape-shifting
Compare and contrast the role of shape-shifting and transformation in “The Shadow Kingdom” with its role in Mourning Dove’s stories (“The Spirit Chief Names the Animal People” and “Coyote Juggles His Eyes”) and in Zora Neale Hurston’s “Uncle Monday.”
Model answer
In all three stories a body can change into something else, and that is a kind of power. The difference is who has the power and how the story feels about it.
In “The Shadow Kingdom,” shape-shifting is the enemy’s weapon. The serpent-men disguise themselves as humans to take over the court, and when they die their real snake faces show. The heroes’ job is to find them and kill them. It makes Kull paranoid about everyone, and he even wonders “if a serpent did not lurk under every mask.”
In Mourning Dove’s stories, transformation is a gift. Coyote oversleeps and gets the name nobody wanted, but the Spirit Chief gives him the power to change his shape so he can get the world ready for people. In “Coyote Juggles His Eyes” his eyes come out of his head and go back in. He also disguises himself like the serpent-men, by killing Pheasant and wearing her skin. But it’s funny instead of scary. He brags about it from a hilltop, and Pheasant comes back to life when her granddaughters put her back in her skin.
In “Uncle Monday,” shape-shifting is where Uncle Monday’s power comes from. He walks out of the lake, people think he turns into an alligator, and he can grow back a torn-off arm. The town fears him but goes to him for help, and he punishes Ant Judy when she challenges him. Nobody tries to expose him or kill him.
So in Howard the shape-shifter is a monster to get rid of. In Mourning Dove and Hurston the shape-shifter is a powerful figure who belongs to the world of the story.